I'm sure it's being done with the best of intentions, but the planned Catalyst Church Easter Egg drop of ten thousand plastic eggs from a helicopter onto a field at Keigwin School Saturday seems like an accident waiting to happen.
A video of an Easter Egg drop in 2007 in Fredricksburg, VA.
The plan has the approval of Middletown Fire Marshall Lewis Larosa.
"The eggs will be dropped in some kind of netting, and the children will be held back until the eggs are dropped," Larosa said. "The FAA has all the jurisdiction about the ceiling at which the helicopter will fly, and it's cargo."
UPDATE:
Middletown Fire Chief Gary Oulette said this afternoon that the church does not have the authorization of the Fire Department to hold the event.
"They would need to have a truck standing by, and that is not authorized," Oulette said.
The Keigwin field may also be sodden from three days of heavy rain, and despite drainage work done under the field, the hunt may turn the field to mud.
The Board of Education building department has also approved the plan based on the approval by the Fire Marshall. A source at the BOE building department said that the church expects 500 children to attend. With a nice day, and the coverage of the story in the Hartford Courant, that may be an underestimate. A quick browse of the web indicate that these egg drops have been popular with Christian churches throughout the country, often attracting thousands of participants.
Neither Mayor Sebastian Giuliano nor Police Chief Patrick McMahon were aware of plans for the Easter Egg drop.
Larosa acknowledges that Keigwin does not have appropriate parking for even 500 attendees.
But, according to at least one report of such an egg-drop in Georgia, the best-laid plans are often trampled by an Easter-crazed mob of children and their parents.
This report from a blogger who attended such a drop in Cartersville GA:
My boys and I arrived at the EggDrop location, which happened to be at the foot of the historic 1,000-year-old Etowah Indian Mounds Historic Site. The first sign of a plan gone wild revealed itself as we approached a fenced-in football field that already held about 5,000 crammed-in people. My first instinct was to turn and run, but I doubt that I could have explained my flight to the 5-year-old with a vice grip on his Easter basket.
EggDrop ground zero was the 50 yard line, and it was surrounded by yellow event tape at a radius of about 20 yards. When the helicopter made its first pass, that yellow event tape was no match for the thousands of screaming kids who burst through to catch the falling plastic eggs. The real problem, though, was that the organizers had not expected that the first drop of around 700 eggs would pelt moms, dads, and unsuspecting eight-year-olds. Panic erupted into chaos when some idiot oranizer with a mega-phone shouted to everyone, “Please, Leave The Field Immediately!” Too late, pal, Pandora’s Easter basket was already wide open.
There were hundreds of crying and lost children and bruised, panicking parents frantically circling the 50 yard line. The second attempt by the then extremely annoying Megaphone-distiller-of-Chaos– “It is Important. You Must Leave The Field, Immediately!” This just exacerbated the frenzy of separated parents and kids who simultaneously trying to obey the Mega-Idiot and search for their scattered families. At one point, I ran over to the M-I and tried to explain to him that no parent is going to leave the field without the right wounded children, myself included.
I further pleaded with him to radio the helicopter and ask them to hold off dropping any eggs until things could be sorted out. He informed me that he did not have radio contact with the helicopter. I didn’t stick around to discuss the comparison of this situation to the underlying theme of Joesph Heller’s most famous book. Instead I dove into the scrum to find my kids. As I pushed my way to the 48 yard line, I saw my two boys sitting on the ground crying. Meanwhile, goofy old RayLiotta in the helicopter was circling with another drop of about 700 more plastic eggs, which cascaded onto the field amidst rippling pops as the egg shells bounced off every man, woman, and child. I ‘m pretty sure that my two boys took the brunt of about salvos before we escaped the perimeter of the field. In fact, as we were leaving the park I counted no fewer than the 7 rounds of egg drops.
While the Board of Education says that Catalyst "has their own insurance," one has to wonder what liability the city, or the BOE bears if a child looks up at the dropping eggs and catches one in the eye.
A wiser friend asked how the $10,000 spent on the helicopter has any bearing on a child's relationship with Jesus at Easter, and perhaps the money would be better spent dropping food or medical supplies in a place like Haiti.
In the immortal words of Arthur"Big Guy"Carlson--"As God is my witness,I thought turkeys could fly."
ReplyDelete$10,000 spent on Easter eggs dropped from the sky should be considered a crime when so many people are suffering from lack of food, shelter
ReplyDeleteand too many things to list.
not to mention the waste of energy this represents with the helicopter and associated travels.
ReplyDeleteWhat about separation between church and state?
ReplyDeleteFirst, the eggs are PLASTIC and they're going to hurt. Second, they're PLASTIC and they're trash that's going to be thrown away. Finally, I don't understand why this is happening on public property, particularly at Keigwin, which is such a confined space with very limited parking. Bad idea, waste of money AND it will undoubtedly cost ME money because of police costs...mark my words.
ReplyDeleteVery disconcerting the police chief doesn't know about this since I hope the church has hired security officers and PRAY no trampling of children and/or adults occurs.
ReplyDeleteI have heard many good things about this church and know that they donate $ and do lots of community service. They seem to be really reaching out to people who have not had a relationship with Jesus and/or a church. This egg drop/hunt seems like an awesome way to maybe get more people aware of their church. I hope everythings goes well. It sounds awesome, my kids are grown or I would bring them. I might be missing something but I am not sure why everyone seems to feel negative about it.
ReplyDeleteOld Saybrook Mom
Because it represents such decadence and commercialism. How could 500 and counting eager children and adults act peaceably at such an event? It's a spectacle or, dare I suggest, a PR stunt, using Easter Sunday, of all days, to attract more church-goers. Doesn't feel quite right.
ReplyDeleteThis is bar none the dumbest idea I have ever heard of for a kids' event. They realize that the field is a swamp at this point, right?
ReplyDelete@Gordon - thanks for the laugh!
Old Saybrook mom, did you read the account of the event in Georgia?? This truly does sound like a COMPLETELY AVOIDABLE disaster waiting to happen. Even a lightweight object dropped from the height of a helicopter will have an injurious impact far beyond its weight ... elementary physics, people.
ReplyDeleteThis is absurd! This is the meaning of Easter? What ever happened to parents hiding a few eggs in the backyard or an Easter egg hunt with the neighbors? Now people have to be enticed to church by the chance of winning flat screen TVs and Wii system?
ReplyDeleteIt is disconcerting that the appropriate authorities don't even know about this. Isn't there some sort of permit needed for an event of this size held on public school grounds? Sounds like chaos at best and an accident waiting to happen. As a taxpayer, I am not in favor of this.
More than the egg drop, I have questions about a church that meets on Sundays at a public school. How does that work?? After the huge fracas about a public school graduation being held at a Roman Catholic church, I'm puzzled that no one is questioning this.
ReplyDeleteI find it disheartening how my fellow man so rapidly objects to anything to do with God and Church. However, I'm not surprised. I totally understand the concern of the safety of attendees at this event. From what I know, Catalyst is taking safety and security very seriously. Im pretty sure the last thing Catalyst wants is someone to get injured. I don't think it's a waste of time or money. Catalyst gets it, what I mean by "gets it" is they understand what the Bible says and really try to live it out in every day life. People say, "take the ten grand and send it to haiti", I'd say that's totally contrary to the ways of God. Catalyst Church resides in Middletown making Middletown their home. God is a God of order. In order to reach haiti, they'd probably have to reach Middletown first. By reach I mean to make an impact by ways of meeting physical and spiritual needs of the community they live in. It's not a waste of money because right here in Middletown there are people totally beaten up by life that have no hope and even people who aren't beaten up by life who have no hope. If an event like this would even give just ONE person hope then it's worth it.
ReplyDeleteYes. One person's "hope" is worth the potential chaos, injuries, and damage to the school field...as long as it's not you or your kid who gets the egg in the eye.
ReplyDeleteAnonymous 10:52, not sure who your "God" is but he's nothing like the Jesus who's written about in the bible. "Suffer the little children," is not to be taken literally.
ReplyDeleteDonate the $10,000 to the event or charity but a Helicopter Company this sounds like an event for disaster hurray for Chief Ouellette
ReplyDeleteHelicopter dropping plastic eggs down toward the ground while young kids await below along with the 100 mile an hour winds associated with the down force from the helicopter blades. This could be a fun event but leave the helicopter factor out. I want a piece of that insurance policy.
This is not what Easter is about. Easter eggs and candy should come second to the true meaning of Easter.
ReplyDeleteWill the crowded masses get to hear the true gospel preached and hear about Jesus' resurection or is this just all about fun and games?
If you look at what Jesus did, He always met physical needs before he met spiritual needs. Granted if you look at it being easter eggs, candy, tvs, and Wiis, thats not much of a physical need. But the even in a whole is to bring hope and joy to broken families. And when they look and see "hey a church did this", they may give church a chance. And thats where they hear the real story behind everything. A lot of people have a bad taste in their mouth about churches, and rightfully so.
ReplyDeleteAs for people quickly to judge about waste of money, perhaps you should look into what this church has already done in the community in its short 6 month history. It may blow you away.
As for people who bring up the georgia incident, why don't you look up the hundreds of times(might be a slight exaggeration, I don't really know how many times its been done before) its been done before without a hitch.
interesting that you relate hope and joy to instant gratification. The ability to resist temptation and to adjust one's attitude rather than going for the quick fix is a sign of intelligence and a calm mind and in the end a much more reliable source of hope and joy then a large symbolic dumping of joy right on your head.. an event that is just as exciting could be done with careful planning, where there is a team effort to decorate the eggs maybe a relay of hiding and finding the eggs, rather than this every man for himself thing that is being done. and by the way i dont see anyone writing anything agains religion so its lame that the supporters are using that as a way to dismiss the criticism
ReplyDelete